Read Next
1-minute Survey
After reading this debate, take our quick survey to see how this information affected your opinion of this topic. We appreciate your feedback.
Discussion Questions
- Should humans colonize space? Why or why not?
- If humans were to colonize space, where should we start: Mars, Earth’s Moon, or another celestial body? And what form should the colonization take: residences, industrialization, or another purpose? Explain your answer(s).
- If humans were to colonize space, how could life on Earth change? And would these changes be good or bad? Explain your answer(s).
Take Action
- Analyze Christopher Schaberg’s position that “We’re Already Colonizing Mars.”
- Consider the language used to talk about humans living in space with Bill Nye.
- Explore George Dvorsky’s position that “Humans Will Never Colonize Mars.”
- Consider how you felt about the issue before reading this article. After reading the pros and cons on this topic, has your thinking changed? If so, how? List two to three ways. If your thoughts have not changed, list two to three ways your better understanding of the “other side of the issue” now helps you better argue your position.
- Push for the position and policies you support by writing U.S. senators and representatives.
Sources
- Ross Andersen, “Exodus: Elon Musk Argues That We Must Put a Million People on Mars if We Are to Ensure That Humanity Has a Future” (September 30, 2014), aeon.com
- Anne Collins Goodyear, “Space Travel Was a Dream for Artists Long before Armstrong Stepped on Moon” (July 15, 2019), business-standard.com
- Authors Calendar, “Savien Cyrano de Bergerac (1619-1655)” (accessed July 23, 2021), authorscalendar.info
- Mike Wright, “Article on Von Braun and Walt Disney” (August 3, 2017), nasa.gov
- Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Yuri Gagarin” (March 23, 2021), eb.com
- NASA, “July 20, 1969: One Giant Leap for Mankind” (July 20, 2019), nasa.gov
- NASA, “60 Moments in NASA History” (accessed July 26, 2021) nasa.gov
- NASA, “The Birth of NASA” (March 28, 2008), nasa.gov
- Rahul Rao, “India’s Human Spaceflight Plans Coming Together Despite Delays” (June 17, 2021), space.com
- Daniel Oberhaus, “The US Hitches Its Final Ride to Space From Russia—for Now” (April 8, 2020), wired.com,
- Mark Memmott, “Last Space Shuttle Lands, Ending 30-Year Era” (July 21, 2011), npr.org
- Laurel Wamsley, “Bezos vs. Branson: The Billionaire Space Race Lifts Off” (July 11, 2021), npr.org
- NASA, “NASA’s SpaceX Crew-2 Astronauts Headed to International Space Station” (April 23, 2021), nasa.gov
- Devin Coldewey, “Virgin Galactic and Richard Branson Celebrate Launch of First Passengers into Space” (July 11, 2021), techcrunch.com
- Jonathan Amos, “Sir Richard Branson Takes off on ’Extraordinary’ Space Flight” (July 11, 2021), bbc.com
- Marcia Dunn, “Jeff Bezos Blasts into Space on Own Rocket: ‘Best Day Ever!,’” (July 21, 2021), apnews.com
- NASA, “Who Was Alan Shepard?” (August 7, 2017), nasa.gov
- Paul Rincon, “Christina Koch: NASA Astronaut Sets New Female Space Record” (February 6, 2020), bbc.com
- NASA, “International Space Station Facts and Figures” (May 13, 2021), nasa.gov
- Pew Research Center, “Majority of Americans Believe It Is Essential That the U.S. Remain a Global Leader in Space” (June 6, 2018), pewresearch.org
- Brian Patrick Green, “Self-Preservation Should Be Humankind’s First Ethical Priority and Therefore Rapid Space Settlement Is Necessary” (June 2019), sciencedirect.com
- Gonzalo Munevar, “An Obligation to Colonize Outer Space” (June 2019), sciencedirect.com
- Kelly C. Smith and Keith Abney, “The Great Colonization Debate” (April 2019), researchgate.net
- Fred Kennedy, “To Colonize Space or Not to Colonize: That Is the Question (For All of Us)” (December 18, 2019), forbes.com
- Matthias Döpfner, “Jeff Bezos Reveals What It’s Like to Build an Empire — and Why He’s Willing to Spend $1 Billion a Year to Fund the Most Important Mission of His Life” (April 28, 2018), businessinsider.com
- Robert Matthews, “When Will Earth Become Uninhabitable?” (accessed July 27, 2021), sciencefocus.com
- Joe Mascaro, “To Save Earth, Go to Mars” (May 11, 2016), aeon.com
- George Dvorsky, “Humans Will Never Colonize Mars” (July 30, 2019), gizmodo.com,
- Matt Williams, “The Future of Space Colonization -- Terraforming or Space Habitats?” (March 10, 2017), phys.org
- NASA Mars Exploration Program, “Mars Terraforming Not Possible Using Present-Day Technology” (July 30, 2018), mars.nasa.gov
- April Glaser, “Elon Musk Will Need One Million Mars Colonists to Get the Ticket Price down to $200,000” (September 27, 2016), vox.com
- Dave Mosher, “NASA Says It Needs a $1.6 Billion ’Down Payment’ from Congress to Send Astronauts Back to the Moon within 5 years” (May 14, 2019), businessinsider.com
- Sarah Fecht, “Stephen Hawking Says We Have 100 Years to Colonize a New Planet-- Or Die. Could We Do It?” (May 4, 2017), popsci.com
- Eric Niiler, “Are Moon Colonies Possible — or the Fantasy of Billionaires?” (July 30, 2018), onezero.com
- Shannon Hall, “The Moon Is a Hazardous Place to Live” (July 8, 2019), nytimes.com
- James Doubek, “NASA Wants to Return to the Moon by 2024, but the Spacesuits Won’t Be Ready” (August 21, 2021), npr.org
- Catherine Shoard, “Film Studio in Space Planned for 2024” (January 20, 2022), theguardian.com
- Jackie Wattles, “A SpaceX Tourism Mission Just Arrived at the ISS. Here’s Everything You Need to Know” (April 9, 2022), cnn.com
- Associated Press, “The 1st Private Astronaut Mission to International Space Station Is Back on Earth” (April 25, 2022), npr.org
- Jasmine Wright, “Harris Congratulates NASA Astronaut Who Spent Record 355 Days in Space” (April 26, 2022), cnn.com
- Mary Kekatos and Gina Sunseri, “Russian Cosmonaut Becomes 1st Person to Spend 1,000 Cumulative Days in Space” (June 5, 2024), abcnews.go.com
- Taylor Orth, “More Now Think NASA Will Get People to Mars by Its 2040 Goal than Thought So Last Year” (April 26, 2023), today.yougov.com
- Patrick Chase, “Trump, Musk Aim for Mars While Reshaping U.S. Space Policy. Will Congress Comply?” (December 1, 2024), medium.com
- Lynsey Chutel, “A Half-Tin Piece of Space Junk Falls onto a Village in Kenya” (January 2, 2025), nytimes
- Alex Galbraith, “‘Just Amazing’: NASA Launches Europa Clipper to Explore Possibily Habitable World Off Jupiter” (October 14, 2024), salon.com
- Blue Origin, “Blue Origin Announces Crew For New Shepard’s 31st Mission” (February 27, 2025), blueorigin.com
- Manuela López Restrepo, “Katy Perry and Gayle King Are Heading to Space as Part of an All-Female Blue Origin Crew” (February 27, 2025), npr.org,
- NBC News, “Live Updates: Blue Origin Completes Space Trip Featuring All-Female Crew” (April 14, 2025), nbcnews.com
- Tony Quine, “Glavkosmos to Sell Seats on Soyuz Missions” (January 28, 2021), spacenews.com
- Francesca Street, “First Space Tourist Dennis Tito: ‘It Was the Greatest Moment of My Life’” (July 20, 2021), cnn.com
- Jackie Wattles, “NASA, SpaceX Launch Astronauts From U.S. Soil for the First Time in a Decade” (May 30, 2020), cnn.com
- Space Adventures, “Blog: The 20th Anniversary of Private Spaceflight” (April 23, 2021), spaceadventures.com
- Space Adventures, “Astronaut Advisory Board” (accessed April 23, 2025), spaceadventures.com
- Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Mark Shuttleworth” (September 13, 2024), britannica.com
- SpaceX, “Starships Are Meant to Fly” (September 10, 2024), spacex.com
- Elizabeth Howell, “Blue Origin: Everything You Need to Know About the Private Spaceflight Company” (November 21, 2023), space.com
- Concordia, “Sir. Richard Branson” (September 22, 2015), concordia.com
- Josh Dinner, “Who Is Virgin Galactic and What Do They Do?” (May 30, 2023), space.com
- Virgin Galactic, “Watch Live: Galactic 01 Spaceflight” (June 29, 2023), youtube.com
- Michael Sheetz, “Virgin Galactic Completes First Commercial Flight in Major Step for Space Tourism Company” (June 29, 2023), cnbc.com
- The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Gregory Olsen” (April 16, 2025), britannica.com
- The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Anousheh Ansari” (September 7, 2024), britannica.com
- The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Charles Simonyi” (October 1, 2024), britannica.com
- The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Richard Garriott” (June 30, 2024), britannica.com
- The Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Guy Laliberté” (Aug 29, 2024), britannica.com
- David Kravets, “Wannabe Space Tourist Wants $21 Million Back Over Scuttled Mission” (September 24, 2008), wired.com
- Deana L. Weibel, “Following the Path That Heroes Carved into History: Space Tourism, Heritage, and Faith in the Future” (January 2, 2020), Religions, mdpi.com
- Steven Bertoni, “Why Cirque Du Soleil Billionaire Guy Laliberte Traveled To Space” (July 9, 2011), forbes.com
- Doug Adler, “Why Did NASA Retire the Space Shuttle?” (May 18, 2023), astronomy.com
- Kenneth Chang, “NASA Hitches a Ride on a Russian Craft, and Begins a New Dependent Phase” (November 12, 2011), nytimes.com
- NBC News, “Russia: No More Space Tourists After 2009” (January 21, 2009), nbcnews.com
- Marcia Dunn, “Tech Billionaire Pulls Off First Private Spacewalk High Above Earth” (September 12, 2024), apnews.com
- Kenneth Chang, “To Get on This SpaceX Flight, You Don’t Have to Be Rich, Just Lucky” (February 1, 2021), nytimes.com
- Eric Berger, “SpaceX Announces First “Free Flyer” Human Spaceflight” (February 1, 2021)
- Amy Thompson, “SpaceX Launches Four Civilians into Orbit on Historic Inspiration4 Flight” (September 16, 2021), space.com
- Julia Musto, “Inspiration4 Leader Places First-Ever Sports Bet from Space” (September 17, 2021), foxbusiness.com
- The Connor Group, “Dayton Entrepreneur First to Reach Space, Ocean Depths in a Year” (accessed April 30, 2025), connorgroup.com
- Axiom Space, “Axiom Mission 3” (accessed April 30, 2025), axiomspace.com
- Space Adventures, “ Space Adventures’ Clients, Yusaku Maezawa and Yozo Hirano, Return From the ISS” (December 20, 2021), spaceadventures.com
- NASA, “Station Visitors” (accessed May 1, 2025), nasa.gov
- Kenneth Chang, “First Private Craft Docks With Space Station” (May 25, 2012), nytimes.com
- William Harwood, “Russian Actress and Director Return to Earth After a Movie Shoot in Space” (October 17, 2021), cbsnews.com
- Editors of Encyclopædia Britannica, “Space Shuttle” (April 18, 2025), britannica.com